Home Ethics Assessing the Appropriateness of the Death Sentence

Assessing the Appropriateness of the Death Sentence

Assessing the Appropriateness of the Death Sentence
Essay (any type) Ethics 1361 words 5 pages 31.10.2026
Download: 62
Writer avatar
Lillian W.
Academic Tutor
Highlights
3+ yrs experience Paper formatting expertise Proofreading & editing Plagiarism checking
94.71%
On-time delivery
5.0
Reviews: 2113
  • Tailored to your requirements
  • Deadlines from 3 hours
  • Easy Refund Policy
Hire writer

The death penalty, as a method of punishment, has inevitably led to various debates, including moral, ethical, and legal perspectives. Advocates of the death sentence highlight both the deterrent option and retributive justice, while opponents focus on the irreversible nature, the possibility of errors, and moral issues. A critical review of capital punishment, focusing on its performance, moral aspects, and social harmony, would provide vital insights into its appropriateness.

The Efficacy of the Death Penalty

The proponents of the death penalty frequently cite the supposedly deterrent effect of capital punishment as one of the reasons for its existence. The proponents of this view believe that the fear of the ultimate punishment by death deters prospective offenders from committing grievous crimes. On the contrary, there is no coherent empirical data on the deterrent effect of the death penalty (Oliphant, 2022). Previous research has failed to prove that the punitive action of capital punishment leads to a decrease in crimes. By comparison, those states that have eradicated capital punishment have not observed a sharp increase in violent crime, which is evidence that other methods of punishment can be equally effective at preventing offenders from committing another crime. For instance, Oliphant (2023) reports that states that halted the use of death sentences did not register higher rates of homicides. For instance, Amnesty International (n.d.) reports that in 2003, 27 years after Canada eradicated the death penalty, its murder rate decreased by 44% compared to 1975 when the death penalty was in effect. Besides, it is imperative to note that the argument that the death penalty deters crimes is based on the assumption that criminals weigh the potential punishments for their crimes before committing offences. This claim is unfounded as most of the violent crimes that result in capital punishment happen in the spur of the moment, providing the offenders with little or no time to think about the consequences (Amnesty et al.). Indeed, the ineffectiveness of the death penalty to prevent crimes undermines its justification on deterrence grounds.

Moreover, the effectiveness of the death penalty in rendering justice is hampered by its irreversible nature. The legal system that was developed to embody objective justice is not perfect. Cases of wrongful conviction, where individuals who have not committed crimes got the death sentence, show built-in weaknesses of the capital punishment system. The risk of executing the death penalty, which cannot be eliminated, significantly undermined the justification of the death penalty. According to Amnesty International (2023), 191 convicts in the United States have been exonerated or released from death row after being proven innocent since 1973. Regrettably, some convicts have been executed despite there being severe doubts of their guilt. The irreversible consequence of capital punishment of an innocent person raises very sensitive ethical dilemmas and moral issues that question the very basis of the death sentence as a tool of justice.

Put your paper in expert hands

Get a custom essay written to your exact requirements – researched, structured, and delivered on time.

Write my essay

Ethical Considerations

On a moral level, the issue of the death penalty leads to numerous fundamental ethical problems concerning the value of life and the lives of every person. Amnesty International (2023) describes the death penalty as the " ultimate cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment." According to Rahimov (2021), the intentional taking of a person's life, especially in the context of punishment, is antagonistic to the fundamental ethical principles. It is the mission of society to keep the value of human life and find ways different from violence and retribution. The use of lethal injection, electrocution, or other equipment causes physical suffering. It violates the dignity of the condemned individual, as well as serves as a tool of violence and dehumanization (Hassan & Gupta, 2021). Also, the death penalty provokes queries about the morals of the state's killing. On the one hand, proponents claim that it is a part of retributive justice; opponents, on the other hand, maintain that it creates a vicious circle of violence and hate, as opposed to a healing process and an end to hostility. The killing of a person with no regard for their crimes denies the value of life and goes against the principles of mercy. As a society, there is a need to find the causes of crimes and violence, which causes the death penalty to be the last resort.

Besides, the death penalty has significantly increased disparities in society. The use of the death penalty often depends on factors like race, class, and region within a country, resulting in unequal sentencing. According to the Equal Justice Initiative (2024), African Americans account for 44% of convicts on death row and 34% of those who have already been executed in the United States despite being a minority population accounting for only 13% of the country's population. Besides, the issuance of the death penalty significantly depends on the victim's race. Equal Justice Initiative (2023) reports that more than 75% of executions for murder were from cases where the victims were white. Regarding the geographical locations, the Equal Justice Initiative reports that more than 80% of lynchings from 1889 to 1918 and legal executions from 1976 have occurred in the South. The disparities underscore the systemic injustices within the criminal justice system. These disparities are an assault on the principles of equality and justice, as they breach the trust of the general public and raise questions of arbitrariness in the punishment.

Alignment with Societal Values

The death penalty is also crossly erratic, with changes in the values of everyday society. Attitudes surrounding the penalty, human rights, and social justice are shifting, and the rationale for the death penalty is becoming steadily less apparent. Several countries all over the world have concluded that the death penalty is not in line with the principles of humanity, dignity, fairness, and justice. According to the Death Penalty Information Center (n.d), 85 countries have completely abolished the death penalty since 1976, with others eradicating it for ordinary crimes. On a global scale, the developmental approach towards abolition reflects that the ethical concerns and practical restrictions associated with capital punishment have been increasingly acknowledged.

It should also be noted that the death penalty misses the point as it does not deal with the underpinning factors of crime and violence. Besides, the death penalty does not meet the goals of punishment. According to Dvoryanskov (2021), the goals of punishment are responsibility, rehabilitation, and restoration. The death penalty does not meet any of these goals. Therefore, more comprehensive approaches are needed to involve spending in prevention, rehabilitation, and restorative justice programs that focus on eliminating the causes of crime and building a just and equitable future. Such approaches should seek to address systemic problems like poverty, inequality, insufficient education, and mental health services to eradicate crimes.

Conclusion

A critical analysis of the death penalty reveals that it is ineffective, unethical, and does not align with societal values. The punishment's inability to deter crime and meet the punishment goal, coupled with its immorality and propagation of disparities, significantly undermine its appropriateness. Therefore, banning capital punishment opens the road to a more just society and reconfirms our humanness and shared values. Consequently, there is a need to replace the death penalty with better punishments and approaches that would not only seek to punish the offenders but also address the underlying causes of crime in society.

Offload drafts to field expert

Our writers can refine your work for better clarity, flow, and higher originality in 3+ hours.

Match with writer
350+ subject experts ready to take on your order
Lillian W.★ 5.0
Lillian W. avatar
3+ yrs experiencePaper formatting expertise

References

  1. Amnesty International (2023, November 13). The death penalty is the ultimate cruel, inhuman, and degrading punishment. https://www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/death-penalty/#:~:text=It%20is%20irreversible%20and%20mistakes,row%20on%20grounds%20of%20innocence.
  2. Amnesty International (n.d.). Does the death penalty deter crime? Getting the facts straight. https://www.amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/act500062008en.pdf
  3. Death Penalty Information Center (n.d). Countries That Have Abolished the Death Penalty Since 1976. https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/international/countries-that-have-abolished-the-death-penalty-since-1976
  4. Dvoryanskov, I. V. (2021). Conceptual issues of the goals of punishment. Penitentsiarnaya nauka= Penitentiary Science, 15(2), 54.
  5. Equal Justice Initiative. (2024, March 11). Death penalty. https://eji.org/issues/death-penalty/
  6. Hassan, A., & Gupta, M. (2021). Possible Pain Caused in Judicial Execution Modes: A Physiological and Pathological Analysis. Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, 15(2).
  7. Oliphant, S. N. (2022). Estimating the effect of death penalty moratoriums on homicide rates using the synthetic control method. Criminology & Public Policy, 21(4), 915–944.
  8. Oliphant, S. (2023). RESEARCH: Halting the Use of the Death Penalty Did Not Result in an Increase in Homicide Rates. https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/news/research-halting-the-use-of-the-death-penalty-did-not-result-in-an-increase-in-homicide-rates
  9. Rahimov, I. M. (2021). Philosophy of the death penalty.